The Rashomon Effect—a new work in progress




There have been numerous cautionary tales about artificial intelligence (AI) presented as a series of effects, including the AI effect, the Eliza effect, and the Clever Hans effect. In the context of generative AI, I‘ve become interested in another effect—the Rashomon effect popularised through Akira Kurasawa’s film, Rashomon.

Rashomon is partly set in a crumbling, derelict city gate symbolising dissolution of truth in medieval Japan, and describes a series of contradictory events that took place in a forest rendered as a mythical space where mysterious and perhaps unknowable things have taken place. Common usage of the Rashomon effect describes the phenomenon of the unreliability of eyewitnesses. In academic contexts the effect defines a framework for thinking, knowing and remembering, which is necessary for understanding situations that are complex and ambiguous. Reference to the Rashomon effect has become pervasive, entering the lexica of filmmaking, journalism, ethnography and the judiciary, and has come to be understood as providing an explanatory paradigm for complexity.

Thinking about generative AI as a movement through data—from word to abstraction into image— the text-prompt-interface of text2image can be conceptualised as a contemporary form of Instruction Art, where language is prioritised in the making of things. My aim is to create algorithmically manipulated versions of the same image data to express how generative AI alters, distorts, and recasts the factual.















 
Selected projects & collaborations by Bruce Gilchrist © 2023